Beyond Compliance – The Power of Voluntary Carbon Markets

In the global race towards decarbonisation, the spotlight often falls on statutory regulations and compliance markets such as the EU ETS or national blending obligations. However, an equally vital, yet often misunderstood, force is mobilising billions of pounds in climate finance: the Voluntary Carbon Market (VCM). Operating outside the scope of legal mandates, the VCM is a decentralised ecosystem where private actors voluntarily buy and sell carbon credits. These credits represent verified reductions or removals of greenhouse gases (GHGs) from the atmosphere, offering a crucial mechanism for organisations to accelerate climate mitigation beyond their direct value chains and unavoidable emissions.

For industry leaders, comprehending the VCM is no longer optional; it is essential for achieving ambitious net-zero targets, demonstrating genuine environmental leadership, and unlocking new financial pathways for sustainable initiatives. This article delves into the mechanics of the VCM, exploring how voluntary carbon credits (often referred to as “voluntary carbon offsets”) are generated, verified, and traded. Crucially, we examine the integral role biogas projects play within this market, dissect the prevailing challenges concerning credit integrity, and illustrate how expert partners such as AFS Energy are indispensable in navigating this complex, yet potent, landscape to foster a credible and impactful net-zero future.

‍

What are Voluntary Carbon Credits? Understanding Emissions Offsets

A voluntary carbon credit is a tradable certificate representing the reduction or removal of one metric tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent (tCO2e) from the atmosphere. Unlike compliance credits (e.g., EUAs, RINs), which are mandated by law, voluntary credits are acquired by companies, organisations, or individuals seeking to offset their emissions or support climate action beyond regulatory obligations. This voluntary nature defines the VCM.

These credits are issued through a project-based system, whereby specific environmental projects are implemented to reduce or remove GHG emissions. These initiatives include:

Emission Removal Projects – physically extracting CO₂ from the atmosphere:

• Afforestation & Reforestation (ARR): Planting or restoring forest ecosystems.
• Blue Carbon: Preserving coastal and marine habitats such as mangroves.
• Biochar: Applying stable charcoal to soil for long-term carbon storage.
• Direct Air Capture (DAC): Using technology to capture CO₂ directly from the air.

Emission Avoidance/Reduction Projects – preventing GHG emissions from being released:

• Renewable Energy: Wind, solar, and hydro displacing fossil fuel sources.
• Energy Efficiency: Improving energy use in buildings and industrial operations.
• REDD+: Avoided deforestation and forest degradation.
• Waste Management: Methane capture from landfills and water treatment.
• Methane Capture & Utilisation: From agriculture, landfills, and wastewater, often converted into biogas or biomethane.
• Improved Cookstoves: Cleaner alternatives reducing emissions and fuel use.
• Agricultural Carbon Projects: Practices like regenerative agriculture to enhance soil carbon storage.

‍

The Journey of a Voluntary Carbon Credit: From Project to Retirement

The credibility of the VCM hinges on a robust lifecycle involving:

1. Project Development: Designed in accordance with approved methodologies.
2. Registration with Carbon Standards: Key standards include:
   • Verra (VCS): Issues Verified Carbon Units (VCUs).
   • Gold Standard (GS): Emphasises sustainable development.
   • American Carbon Registry (ACR) and Climate Action Reserve (CAR) in North America.
3. Independent Validation and Verification: Audits ensure that reductions are genuine.
4. Credit Issuance: Recorded in public registries for transparency.
5. Trading: Credits change hands via brokers, exchanges, or direct sales.
6. Retirement: Once used, a credit is retired to prevent reuse and ensure uniqueness.

‍

Pillars of Trust: What Makes a High-Quality Credit

For a credit to be deemed credible, it must be:

• Real – Emission reduction must actually occur.
• Measurable – Quantifiable in a verifiable way.
• Additional – Would not have occurred without the project or funding.
• Unique – No double-counting of the emissions reduction.
• Permanent – Long-term impact, typically 100 years, with safeguards.
• Risk Managed – Accountable to future uncertainties and market changes.
• Inclusive of Co-benefits – Projects should support local communities, biodiversity, and livelihoods.

‍

Biogas Projects: Biomethane’s Rising Influence in the VCM

Biomethane projects, especially those capturing methane from waste, are gaining recognition for their high-quality contributions. These projects are pivotal because:

• Methane Avoidance: Preventing release of this highly potent GHG.
• Fossil Fuel Displacement: Biomethane replaces traditional fuels.
• Carbon Negative Potential: Some projects draw down more GHGs than they emit.

Such projects are increasingly favoured in the VCM due to their measurable climate benefits and valuable local co-benefits.

‍

Challenges and Integrity Concerns

The VCM is evolving, but not without scrutiny. Key concerns include:

• Greenwashing Risks: Questionable claims around additionality or permanence.
• Lack of Standardisation: No single universal framework creates inconsistency.
• Transparency Gaps: Limited access to data restricts independent validation.
• Scalability Issues: Balancing supply and demand without compromising quality.
• Overlapping Claims: Ensuring alignment between voluntary and compliance markets.

Raising Standards: ICVCM and VCMI Initiatives

To enhance the VCM’s credibility:

• ICVCM (Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market): Develops Core Carbon Principles (CCPs) to benchmark quality.
• VCMI (Voluntary Carbon Markets Integrity Initiative): Offers guidance on responsible credit usage, emphasising internal reductions before offsets.

These initiatives aim to bolster trust, transparency, and rigour.

‍

Market Outlook and Emerging Trends

Despite concerns, the VCM has grown rapidly:

• Market Size: Valued at USD 4.04 billion (2024), projected to reach nearly USD 48 billion by 2035.
• Key Trends:
  • A shift towards high-quality, recent-vintage, and removal-based credits.
  • Decline of basic renewable energy credits unless additionality is proven.
  • Technology integration (e.g., blockchain) for traceability and trust.

Biogas and landfill gas projects continue to attract interest for their verifiable impact and multiple co-benefits.

‍

AFS Energy: Your Guide to a High-Integrity VCM

Navigating the VCM requires expertise. AFS Energy supports clients through:

• Sourcing High-Integrity Credits: Particularly from biomethane.
• Strategic Procurement: Aligning credits with decarbonisation strategies.
• Ensuring Credible Claims: Aligning with VCMI and best practice.
• Connecting Stakeholders: Linking project developers with buyers.
• Market Intelligence: Real-time insights into prices and standards.
• Integrated Solutions: Combining voluntary credits with compliance strategies.

‍

The VCM as a Catalyst for Net-Zero

The Voluntary Carbon Market is not a peripheral mechanism - it is a driving force in global decarbonisation. Through its capacity to mobilise private capital and incentivise emissions reductions, it complements regulatory frameworks and accelerates progress.

Biomethane projects stand out in this landscape for their measurable impact and local advantages. As frameworks like ICVCM and VCMI continue to refine the market’s integrity, organisations can more confidently leverage carbon credits. With guidance from experienced partners such as AFS Energy, businesses can transform their climate ambitions into credible, measurable action, accelerating their journey to net-zero.